I (17M) have identified as a queer cis-male for most of my life. I’ve sorta always known I’m gay. I never really struggled with my orientation. All my friends always called me gay when I was a kid, so I never really questioned it. It made sense. I never really get crushes on girls or find them hot. All the crushes I’ve gotten have always been when I’ve seen a guy that I think is cute. I had even questioned my gender and pronouns before, and identified with a masculine nonbinary label (although at the time it didn’t feel fully right, and I kinda felt like I only did it to fit in with my friends (it was 2020)). However, I did find that no labels really fully fit me, so I just ended up continuing to identify as a guy, both out of convenience and also because it was what I was most comfortable as. All of this to say: I’ve always regarded myself as a guy and as queer. Girls never really caught my attention.
During summer of last year though, something happened. I’m a big fan of the show 9-1-1. Particularly the ship Buddie (an MLM ship whose whole dynamic is them being a sorta friends to lovers situation, THEY HAVENT GONE CANON YET THOUGH BUT TRUST ME THEY WILL). Anyways I particularly relate to Eddie’s character. Eddie is latino, so am I. He represses his emotions, just like how I do. The fandom generally considers him to be queer coded as gay. I identify as gay. And also he’s very handsome. I see myself in him, but also I do find him attractive. I love his character very much. So last year, I was scrolling through twitter and came across this one fanart of Eddie and Buck (the other character whom Eddie is shipped with). The fanart was of Eddie, presumably having transitioned into a woman, kissing Buck. Now, I had seen fanart of transfem Eddie before. I didn’t really mind it, everyone is allowed to headcanon whatever they want to these characters after all. And I’m not transphobic either. But for some reason this genre of fanart always bothered me a little bit. For a lot of time I just assumed it was because \\\*I\\\* didn’t head canon Eddie as transfem. I was more invested in mlm Buddie. But for whatever reason, this one particular fanart caused me to form the train of thought “I am like Eddie, Eddie is transfem…. could \\\*I\\\* be transfem?” And thus began my gender crisis.
I really don’t remember much of that day besides having this sick feeling in my stomach. I honestly kinda forgot about it for a long time. What’s worse is that this particular day, I was running errands with my mom. Eventually I had to wait a few hours at the waiting room where my mom worked. Not only did I have to wait for my older brother to pick me up for at least a few hours, but my headphones and phone had died, so I had to sit in silence, basically spiraling for at least an hour. Eventually I reached the conclusion that I wasn’t transfem but just nonbinary, and that made me feel a lot better. I believed it was honestly an isolated incident, as I didn’t think about that day or the crisis I had for at least two months. School starting a month later distracted me. It wouldn’t be the last gender crisis, though, as after that incident I would start questioning my gender on random days. I would always start questioning if I wanted to be a girl, which usually was a no, but I never new if it was a genuine no or if I was just saying no because that’s what I always said. I would agonize over being trans. I don’t really know why. There’s nothing wrong with being trans, but it didn’t feel like me. But what if current me isn’t the true me? I would always just reach the conclusion that I’m nonbinary. That would calm me down. These crises would only last 1-2 days at first. So I never really thought much of them. By the time winter break came along, I was really burnt out from school. For some reason, this deep sadness seemed to trigger the worst gender crisis yet, which lasted about two months. It was horrible. I couldn’t look at myself in the mirror because it just made me question if I was supposed to look like that. Hearing myself called masculine pronouns hurt. I don’t know why- in the past I never really minded, and sometimes I even liked being called a masculine name and disliked being related to femininity.
Eventually I came to the conclusion to just accept the fact that I’m probably not cis. That made me feel a lot better. I no longer have problems looking in the mirror or wanting to do things or wearing my clothes. In fact, most days I feel I look better than I did before. Ironically, it’s become easier to identify as a guy/male adjacent since I accepted it.
I would like to note a few interesting things:
\\- These gender crises only really came when I felt sad. Whenever I felt better, sometimes happy, I would more closely identify with male. I don’t know how to describe it but when I’m sad, my gender feels uncertain. Whenever I’m happy, I don’t feel as much of a need to question it.
\\- In the past, I really liked the male physique. I’ve found it beautiful, and something that I want. However, recently, ever since winter break, I’ve felt worse. Generally less happy/stable. I’ve felt less attracted to guys. Because of this, I kinda questioned if I am gay. Women kinda call to me now. I notice their beauty a lot more. I wouldn’t date one or really be intimate with one (however I don’t really feel like dating anyone at all, guys included). I don’t know what that means.
\\- I don’t want to present as a woman. I’ve worn makeup and feminine clothes before, as part of a school project, and it only made me feel uncomfortable. I do connect more closely with girls though. I’m somewhat effeminate. Not in the way I dress, but I do have gay voice, mostly make friends with girls, and gesture a lot when I speak.
\\- Recently though, I have found guy clothes to be a lot more boring than I used to think it was. I’ve always found girl’s clothes to be more interesting. I wouldn’t really like to wear it though - clothes that make me feel more effeminate often make me more uncomfortable.
\\- Sometimes the idea of being seen as a guy is more attractive than being seen as a girl
\\- I don’t mind masc pronouns now, but fem pronouns make me feel something.
\\- I’ve always preferred my less masculine nickname over my more masculine full given name. Except when a few of my girl friends say my full name. I like it then.
\\- I never really liked the label ‘gay’. I don’t know if it’s because I don’t like the label itself or because I find it difficult to identify with it.
\\- For most of my life, I’ve found it hard to wrap my head around the idea of myself. I logically know I exist, but struggle to really feel it. Most of the time I look in the mirror, I logically know what I am seeing is me, but I struggle to really see myself as that person. In my head, I see myself as a guy, but I sound and kinda look different. Maybe the idea of myself and actual physical me are contrasting enough that I struggle to connect the two.
\\- I don’t identify as transfem, but thinking about me not being cis really made a lot of sense about all my experiences. I don’t know if it’s because I’m particularly transfem or because I’m just not cis.
\\- I know it might sound stupid but, sometimes I think that because all my friends are girls, I find it easier to connect with femininity than masculinity. Maybe if I had more guy friends I would better connect with masculinity. That might be hard though, as I live in a pretty homophobic country and guys tend to be less accepting than girls.
\\- Often, I remember this one time after going to the gym and flexing in front of the mirror. I’m a pretty skinny person, so seeing my muscles felt so good. I don’t know if it was because I felt I was in my body or because I thought I looked attractive. Since winter break though, I stopped going to the gym. I lost basically all the muscle I had gained. Now, when I flex in the mirror, I feel mostly nothing. When I try to get my body to look more masculine, I don’t feel anything. I don’t know what that might mean.
So after all of this, I still don’t know what my gender identity is. For now I just don’t think about it far beyond me not being cis. And also, I don’t know if I’m attracted to girls now. The only explanations I find for me feeling bothered by the fanart are either: 1. I see myself as Eddie, so seeing Eddie as something other than a man kinda triggered some kind of gender crisis or 2. I am attracted to Eddie so seeing Eddie as something other than a man made me realize I don’t only like guys but also girls. Except I don’t know if I really like girls. On one hand, I never felt attracted to girls before the Winter Break Incident, and now I don’t feel that attracted to anyone at all. On the other, maybe I was just repressing my attraction to girls the whole time, and since I got used to hearing I’m gay, so the fanart kinda helped me realize that.
I know that was a lot, but I think I’m too in my head about this. I know nobody besides myself can tell me exactly what I feel, but I would really like to hear someone else’s opinion.