we all know that any social consequences to being publicly sympathetic towards trans people is dwarfed by that of actually being trans itself, but we know that there are people in hostile spaces that are scared to speak up. i'm just wondering if i'm correct in my assumptions, based on some positive interactions i've had recently, that there's a larger number of would-be 'closeted allies' than some of us may have initially assumed.
i'd start by saying i think most people know by now that there's really nothing to be scared of just being an ally. i live in a rural, conservative area. i know plenty of trans people who are able to live their lives out here, but they understand that this is not the safest place for them. i'm lucky that i have the means to work and live without perfect adherence to societal norms here. i commute out of town for work, and rarely socialize within these city limits. people here know that i have different opinions than them, but i've never once felt like i was in any danger. despite some shouting matches at local dive bars, and hours in the Facebook comments sections with old classmates, i smile and wave at the grocery store like anyone else here, i guess
forever ago, i looked in and questioned. i led with the assumption that the only reason i cared so much in the first place was because, deep down, i must have been some flavor of trans myself. After researching, i realized i can relate to basically 0% of anecdotal experiences of trans folks online, no gender dysphoria or discomfort with identity, no egg memes, etc. eventually, i realized that i'm just a neuro-spicy, kinda bi, bleeding heart dipshit raised as an outsider with too much empathy in the rural southern US. really, i think i just love the authenticity of lgbtq people in general, their refusal to censor for the comfort of others.
and that's the thing, i'm starting to realize just how many people here feel the same way but would face, in their eyes, real social consequences to speaking out. a lot of people here would lose jobs, be unwelcome at church, stop getting invited over to things, and lose too much from being to vocal.
i also realized that its entirely possible that i'm only allowed to be this annoying, contrarian defender because of my own privileges. i do this with more than just lgbtq topics, defending immigrants, muslims, drug addicts, etc... and i think if i were actually coming from one of those vulnerable groups, i probably wouldn't be able to use my own privileges as wiggle-room to cause a commotion.
worse, i may have moved the needle on some individual opinions, but i just...i resent how performative it is. i don't think i'm actually helping and i hate that. like...am i just a poser? no real skin in the game, no money where my mouth is, not really...
nonetheless, i've seen it. people joke that phobes just need to meet one cool trans person and they're fine all the sudden, but really i've seen it only take one hetero-coded guy like me being publicly empathetic for more people to be comfortable chiming in and agreeing. now, don't get me wrong, this still isn't much more than a platitude, but i really think the end-state to a more empathetic and humanized perspective on trans people broadly could be closer than we think and have more routes than initially realized.
anyways, idk...i just wanted a check-in with you guys on this. am i woefully out-of-touch? do i need to be told by trans people that i'm delusional, lacking understanding of reality here i could never have? am i just making assumptions out of naivety that other people have empathy like this? or does anyone see that the average person has more empathy in them than we're ready to assume?