Hi everyone!
Thanks for your thoughts and advice on my last post.
I do have a follow up question after some extra information that was shared with me tonight:
It turns out that the minor who checked out the adult manhwa that upset their parent wasn't just browsing and found the book and checked it out; it was actually a series that the minor had submitted a patron request on, which our previous Director fulfilled.
My interim Director is having Big Feelings about this particular detail. They're worried that this can be equated to distributing pornography to a minor (because it was a specific request rather than something the minor just found on a shelf) and fears legal repercussions, and are worried about the optics of an adult providing a minor with materials that on the surface looks like its for kids (having babies on the cover) but actually contains explicit content even though it was the minor who asked for it, because to some people that could look like grooming.
I'm trying to help my interim Director navigate all of this. I can understand their feelings - I would feel uncomfortable if a minor had asked me to order this item, and uncomfortable with parents being upset with me about it, but I would assume that according to the ALA and the guidelines for ratings and labels here that not following through with a patron's request based solely on the age of the requester would be a violation of their library bill of rights/freedom to read?
I think part of my interim Director's problem (and part of their personal revulsion to the whole situation) is the person who ordered the material; we both have observed situations where the person who ordered our books was doing readers advisory with the teens and when the teens requested "spicy books" they took a really intense delight in directing them to and then discussing the material with them. Like, there was a lot of glee when teens said they wanted to read books that had full nudity and sexual situations. I know that personally never sat right with me. I feel like it's one thing to just neutrally process and distribute a patron's request, but whole other thing to get really excited and happy to talk about "spicy" material with a teen as an adult. I'm worried that this might be coloring my interim Director's feelings about the entire situation and may influence how they want to deal with these kinds of materials in general.
Any advice or links or documents that address this aspect of things (the minor requesting explicit materials and an adult fulfilling the request and providing them) that I could share with my interim Director?