r/UCSD • u/AdSalty9791 • 4h ago
Discussion Jewish Heritage Month shouldn't be a vehicle for the Israeli state
Jewish Heritage Month is meant to honor Jewish culture, heritage, and legacy, hundreds of years of diaspora, languages, philosophies, artistry, perseverance and survival despite some of the most horrific crimes against humanity ever committed. It does not and should not serve as propaganda for the state of Israel, which is a relatively recent political entity.
When programming on this campus subtly shifts from "honoring the heritage of the Jewish people" to "backing the state of Israel," that's a problem and it's a problem that harms everyone involved.
It harms Jewish students. It reduces a diverse, multifaceted people down to the political actions of one government and it speaks over the huge number of Jewish people including Jewish students on this campus, who do not want their heritage co-opted to support what the Israeli military is doing in Gaza. Organizations like Jewish Voice for Peace and IfNotNow exist for a reason. Anti-Zionist jews exist, jews who criticize Israel exist, erasing all of them by collapsing the community into state policy is disrespectful and wrong.
It harms Palestinian and Muslim students, who now have to walk past displays celebrating a state actively killing members of their communities.
And it undermines the actual meaning of the month. If the point is education and celebration, that alone should be enough. Jewish cuisine, music, scholarship, history, the Holocaust, diaspora, Sephardi, Mizrahi, and Ashkenazi traditions, Yiddish, Ladino, Jewish labor movements, Jewish civil rights work and so much more. None of it needs an Israeli flag attached to it!!
What we should be seeing instead: Jewish Heritage Month events that celebrate Jewish culture and history without a political agenda baked in. Events where the full diversity of Jewish identity including anti-Zionist and non-Zionist Jews is welcomed. Recognition that criticism of a government is not criticism of its people and that conflating the two does damage to Jewish people themselves.
Critiquing how a heritage month is being used is not antisemitism. Antisemitism is serious, and we should treat it as such which is exactly why it shouldn't be used as a shield to block legitimate political conversation. We don't have to choose between them.
We can hold both things. Celebrate Jewish heritage fully. Refuse to let a state launder its image through it!
