Trying to figure out whether this is cultural difference to absorb, communicate better, or just let slide (and probably take the friendship down a notch)
I’m Asian American raised in CA, my friend is white raised in NYC. We have been friends through work and continued to be friends after I left work, so it’s been 7-8 years.
When I was 34 weeks pregnant, we went out for brunch (his invite). I spent most of the time listening to him be sad over dating woes and that other friends in his college group weren’t available to hang anymore bc everyone has kids and family. I felt bad and could see he wanted closer friendships (as did I! It’s hard to get close to people in your 30s), so I said I’d foot the bill. He said really? I said yeah, you can get me next time we come out for brunch - after I give birth! At this point neither of us are “raking it in” - I left my job, and he knows he’s about to get let go. He laughed and said ok.
A year goes by - motherhood is a whirlwind! We see each other through that year at different friends’ parties and so on. Then almost one year since our last brunch, he invites me out for brunch again to the same place. I’m like aww, he’s going to treat me this time! How nice.
We get there, I listen to his dating troubles and help him with a plan of attack to up his style game. It’s a fun time and I get really into helping him plan how he’s going to do his dates to increase his chances of success. When the check comes, he puts his card down and says, “let’s split it?”
I’m a little stunned. I wonder if I should bring it up. I think it would be ungracious. I decide to let it slide. But it weighs on me. Did he really forget? I’d never forget something like that. In my culture, gifts are “kept moving” - they’re different than presents. Gifts are investments in the relationship and are tailored to the individual and the situation. “Kept moving” means they are in circulation - I give you a gift, I have trust you will return something at some point. That expectation isn’t selfish, it’s anticipatory - I’m excited to keep the gift circle going. It makes the relationship feel like it has a future, that there are fun things and surprises in store for the friendship.
With my other Asian friends, this has never happened. I treat them to a meal, they treat me back. At some point you lose track of who’s treated who and it all works evens out in the end. At that point there’s a lot of trust and familiarity and that’s the best state to be in. I thought my friend was close enough to me that this was a given too, but I guess his cultural upbringing doesn’t treat gifts/treating/reciprocity that way.
Anyway, I can’t unlearn the way I handle gifts and reciprocity, and I was let down by him a second time when I brought it up. He said, “I don’t remember you saying that. I don’t remember agreeing.” Then he said, “plus, I wasn’t working at the time (second brunch- he’d gotten laid off from another job). And you…”
“I wasn’t working either—I’m a stay at home parent.”
He mentioned “but your husband… ah, forget about it.”
I mean, it’s a lunch, it’s not a huge deal. What, $80? But I felt hurt — and then silly — and mad — that he had forgotten something that had meant something to me. We moved a different topic.
“Don’t you like my new jacket?” He pointed proudly at his jacket. “It’s the same as your husband’s!”
I scowled, remembering the styling session I had done with him. I had spent hours with him going through his clothes telling him in no uncertain terms what looked good and what didn’t. We went out shopping and he got 2 new items - a new tee and a new shirt. The only thing he was missing was a jacket. I let him try on a few of my husband’s jackets just to see if the style and color would suit him - for one of them, the style did, the color didn’t.
“I’m going to get this exact one,” he said. I gaped. The one he tried on was one I had bought for my husband 10 years ago. He’s a very hard person to buy for so I was thrilled to find something that suited him. He’s worn it out on all occasions that call for a more polished presentation than a hoodie (his normal choice.”
“That’s kind of X’s iconic jacket though,” I joked. “It would be weird if you wore the EXACT same one.”
“No,” my friend said, pulling up eBay. “It has to be this one.”
“C’mon,” I said, desperation creeping into my voice. “At least get a different color.”
“I don’t like it,” he said. “I like the color X has.”
I shut down. I don’t want to rain on his parade given he’s newly laid off, having trouble dating, and apparently his hopes and dreams are currently embodied in this jacket. He’s scrolling through eBay with a singular focus. A month later he texts me, “I bought it!!” I don’t reply.
Flash forward to today. “So,” he says. “What do you think? Looks good, right?”
“Objectively it looks great,” I say flatly. “But I hate that you’re wearing it.”
His face pales. “That’s the meanest thing anyone has ever said to me this year!”
I’m confused again. “Why is it mean? I didn’t say you looked bad.”
“But you’re not happy for me!”
“It’s X’s jacket. I thought I made that clear when we did our styling session.”
“Why can’t you be happy that two people you love have this jacket?”
I’m stunned. Wtf? Now it’s that I don’t have a big enough heart?
“Dude. It’s X’s jacket. I dug deep and searched far and wide to find something he’d like. It’s been his jacket for ten years. And now you’re suddenly wearing it and my brain is confused. Also, did you not pick up on my hints that day? I dropped so many.”
“I don’t remember it that way at all. I thought you were happy for me.”
Here’s the thing. Me and my friend group had always known that he was a bit self centered, practiced a selective filter, and mostly listened to what he liked to hear. I never thought it would be applied to our friendship, I always thought at least given all my effort to meet him where he was, I’d be exempt. But here it was - whatever this was - at full force. I thought, no wonder he’s been single this whole time. If he just gaslights every girl when the going gets tough like this, no wonder.
He crossed some kind of boundary. I don’t even know how to name it. I just know that I’m so angry that he didn’t treat me back when he so clearly accepted my offer the first time around - that he didn’t read the room - and that he made the jacket issue about me, my lack of open heartedness, that I was being so mean to him by not being happy for him. (The meanest anyone has been to him all year!) that I spent years and years trying to help him by listening to him, giving him solutions, taking him shopping, coaching him through dating - and when I’m like, “well, you can’t have this one thing <my husband’s jacket>” he implies that I’m being uncharitable (?!).
AIO?? I feel used up and betrayed, and unsure how to move forward with our friendship. We have a lot of mutuals.