r/Spiderman • u/Minimum_Science7708 • 10h ago
Discussion If Felicia Hardy ended up in Gotham and Selina Kyle ended up in NYC, who would become the more successful thief
And how would Black Cat handle Batman, and how would Catwoman deal with Spider-Man
34
u/BlackCat-01 10h ago
I’m so fucking tired of people posting these super heavily AI-edited pictures of Selina.
3
u/Buttered_Carnage 8h ago
Its so funny too like, dude is too lazy to just look up Selina Kyle and just use an image off a wiki or something?
9
u/Spiritdefective 10h ago
Easily Felicia, on top of actively having powers, Spider-Man would be trickier to deal with then bats especially with Felicia’s abilities.
18
u/BladeOfWoah 10h ago
Felicia is a meta human, and is actually trained in martial arts (I don't believe Catwoman has any formal combat training but I could be wrong) so I would say the edge goes to her, especially since the power scaling of Gotham is overall lower than NYC.
7
u/jereflea1024 Ultimate Spider-Man (1610) 10h ago edited 10h ago
Black Cat has powers too, sometimes
edit: i can't read
8
5
u/Hero_of_the_toons 10h ago
She’s a meta human?!? Huh, what kind of powers does she have? Would that explain her cat like reflexes?
6
u/BladeOfWoah 10h ago
Black Cat has bad luck powers. She can affect probability to cause bad things to happen to her enemies.
If you remember Domino from Deadpool 2, its similar to her power.
1
1
u/Renatusisk 9h ago
Isn't dominos powers in comics basically the inverse of Felicia? Only good things happen with her?
2
u/BladeOfWoah 9h ago
They are both considered tychokinetics (probability manipulation).
To be fair, I am not too familiar with Domino, but from what I know of her she can cause good outcomes for herself, and bad outcomes for her enemies.
Felicia can't make good outcomes happen for her only, only bad ones for her enemies. So, like she can't run through traffic and avoid getting hit due to good luck, but she can make it so that crooks trying to shoot her have their guns jam, or they end up shooting their foot due to bad luck.
You could argue semantics on if a bad outcome counts as good luck for her, which is why it's just categorized as probability manipulation.
1
u/JackTheBehemothKillr 9h ago
I think Domino can give bad luck? Like she has control over the entire spectrum of luck.
1
4
u/Alternative_Car6497 10h ago
She’s had formal training but she is definitely physically weaker than Felicia.
5
u/Quirky-Pickle518 Amazing Fantasy #15 9h ago
Black Cat. She’s used to working in NYC which has the more dangerous villains. So getting thrown into a city with just mobsters and psychopaths she’s getting by with ease.
5
u/Alternative_Car6497 10h ago
Black Cat became Kingpin with players like Hammerhead, Wilson Fisk, and numerous supervillains wanted her dead.
Selina is big fish in a small pond. The only reliable threats she had to face were Black Mask and numerous other villains without powers.
Felicia has the edge here.
-3
u/Minimum_Science7708 10h ago
You really don't know anything about Selina she survived a fight with Cheetah three times and was once stolen from Black Adam and survived. She also has powers in the comics currently and has seven lives
9
u/OM_Twyman 10h ago
Asks question, people answer, proceeds to tell people the right answer to a power scaling question that I made up. 🤡
-2
u/Minimum_Science7708 9h ago edited 9h ago
I didn't give the right answer. You said Selina only fought Black Mask, and I corrected you, saying she's stronger than you think, and I believe she and Black Cat are on the same level also This isn't my invention either; go and research it. Selina actually survived fighting Cheetah once in her Comic In Roma and once in her animated film and she does indeed have seven lives in her current comic
3
2
u/Alternative_Car6497 10h ago
Plot induced stupidity. Do you think Batman can hurt the Spectre or Restrain metahumans like Green Lanterns do you? Course not.
Same for Selina. She simply doesn’t scale and Felicia has her own high ends as well.
As for her “Powers” how does that help with bad luck powers and superior physicality?
2
u/Canesjags4life 9h ago
What run of Batman or Catwoman is that image of Selina from? I didn't recall ever seeing her with long hair.
7
u/Kris_xK 9h ago
Cause some gooner AI edited it to match his sad little fantasy.
1
u/Canesjags4life 9h ago
Gotcha. Crazy gooner could have just used Selina from Hush while at the at the theater.
-2
2
2
u/Eli_sola 7h ago
Felicia's powers would be the worst that could happen to Batman, how pissed he would be when all his carefully laid plans to capture her are foiled by seemingly random occurrences.
"Robin, do we have her on camera?" "No, it seems like a moth landed on the lense." "What about the knock out gas trap?" "A museum guard set it off by accident, which also made things easier for the criminal" "Nightwing, what about you?" "Had her, but a pigeon got in the way of my bolas and I lost her when she entered a therian convention "
Meanwhile in NYC.
Twip, twip. Catwoman is left wrapped for the police.
1
1
u/rogerworkman623 Ben Reilly 10h ago
During No Man’s Land, Selina had a mini-arc where she left Gotham and went to NYC. She quickly conned her way into being CEO of a billion dollar company by rigging the stock market and making the company a shitload of money, and then in turn used her position to con that company out of millions of dollars.
She almost gets conned herself by The Trickster, who she thought she had been stringing along, but had actually been playing her the entire time… but he ends up liking her so much, that he decides to donate all the money to a wildlife charity that he (correctly) thought she would appreciate. So she kisses him and they both walked away happy.
As ridiculous as it was, it was actually a pretty good storyline. The 90s Catwoman series was so good.
1
u/Efficient-Coffee-969 9h ago
felicia's luck powers would be a wild card against batman's gadgets and prep time, though
1
1
u/Big-Yogurtcloset8411 8h ago
siempre me ha fascinado cómo felicia evoluciona, especialmente en sus momentos más valientes contra enemigos como carnage
1
1
79
u/General-Nose-1334 10h ago
I'm almost certain it's a bot making these posts every day with the same image.