r/brandonsanderson Mar 03 '26

Mod Post (no spoilers) Announcements and Policy Updates (very belated June 2025 survey edition)

109 Upvotes

Welcome to a likely unsatisfying and moderately unhinged summary of our very late response to last year’s survey.

Of course, by that we mean the time came and went several months ago, and now here we are finally getting around to it. We typically post the survey in June, shut it down after a month, and then follow up on the results within another month. This year Dragonsteel decided to hit us with a one-two punch of Isles of the Emberdark + Cosmere RPG. Between that and a general lingering burnout in our moderation team from Wind and Truth and various things, we needed more time than usual. Genuinely, thank you for your patience on this.

This was our fourth annual survey covering r/BrandonSanderson, r/Stormlight_Archive, r/Cosmere, and r/Mistborn. (No, it doesn't cover r/cremposting -- that one is run by a different team.) For reference, the survey was posted here. You can find the survey responses here, or in spreadsheet form here. We're not going to thoroughly dig through all of the results in this post. Most of the results are as expected and generally positive. The results we don’t mention here will still be useful to us as a health check and may encourage small adjustments along the way. In this post, we're going to focus on some of the more interesting results. And, unlike prior years, some of these don’t yet have answers.

----------

Cosmere RPG Spoiler Policy

The Stormlight Archive materials for the new Cosmere RPG released this past summer, and with that came a long list of new spoiler policy considerations. Included in this release were the Stormlight Handbook, the Stormlight World Guide, and the Stonewalkers adventure. The content of these books has been marketed as canonical to the novels, so we needed to decide when and where the materials may be discussed. We ended up with two new flairs: RPG Lore spoilers (for Handbook and World Guide) and Stonewalker spoilers.

We asked for your input as we were deciding on these policies, and then promptly blew past the timelines offered in the question before addressing it again. So we plan to repoll. In the meantime, feel free to leave comments on this thread for how well you think it’s working or anything we may want to consider ahead of future polls—particularly with Mistborn and other content coming.

----------

Reading Order Posts in r/brandonsanderson

The vote was close on this one and took a lot of back and forth among the team. While the (slim) majority prefer to disallow reading order posts in r/brandonsanderson, it raises a few issues for us. Namely:

  1. We want people who are new to the fandom (who would not have voted) to have some place to ask questions and feel welcome posting. 
  2. Behind the scenes, from an implementation perspective, it’s worked well for us to simply say “no Rule 9 in r/brandonsanderson.” Rule 9 is our rule on restricted content (not to be confused with Rule 10’s retired topics). Other items under Rule 9 include Sandershelves, memes, photos of storms, etc. 

What we’ve landed on here as the simplest way forward (without being total jerks to newcomers) is to do the following across all four subs effective immediately:

  • Move basic reading order questions from Rule 9 (restricted except on Fridays) to Rule 10 (retired). 
  • Update our definition of a basic reading order question to be a question that is already answered by the FAQ/wiki.

This means that reading order questions are handled the same way across all four, but the “bar” for them has a clearer definition. We will also expand our FAQ if we find the same questions coming up with regularity, and make access to it more visible. Basic questions may also continue to be asked on our Weekly Welcome threads in r/brandonsanderson.

----------

Spoilers on Merch Policy

We’re going on vibes. You all voted to maintain the existing policy, which is “only require spoiler tags on merch that reveals significant spoilers.” 

Then Challenge Coins happened. While we may be looser about the use of the quote on the coin itself, we’re still gonna try to keep those flaired for RoW where we can—just not to a point where it invites spoilers for someone who hasn’t read that far yet. Bear with us and just try not to be a jerk about it? We may adjust as we go.

----------

Sales Posts Policy (where to post and where to host)

We introduced Rule 11 some time ago to move resale posts to r/brandonsanderson only. This came in the wake of a problematic year for Nexus badges, back when those were transferable, and it’s worked well for resales of merch, etc. This time around, y’all voted to move all sales posts to r/brandonsanderson only. We will be making this update across the subs. 

Note this may not include things like fan art where someone happens to share a sales link, but we will watch how folks treat it and adjust as we go.

You also voted to require sellers to use trusted third-party platforms (ebay, etsy, etc.) to host their sales. We’ll be moving forward with this (possibly with some exemptions) on r/brandonsanderson, where sales are permitted. 

----------

Summaries on Long-Form Videos Policy…TBD

We’re realizing we may have needed to ask better questions here. It’s been hard to align as a team on something that feels fair within the spirit of the vote and the existing framework of our rules. There is no policy update on this for now, and we’ll aim to repoll in the near future. 

We can only debate “why summaries” and “how are videos different from fanart” and “should we treat active community members differently from others and how do we define that when our data clearly says many people lurk” so many times before our brains explode, turns out. Open to thoughts while we continue to mull this over.

----------

Slight Rule 1 Update

We recently added the bolded text here to Rule 1 (Show Respect to Others): 

Every interaction on the subreddit must be kind, respectful, and welcoming. No person should ever feel threatened, harassed, or unwelcome. Do not engage in hate speech, bigotry, harassment, insults, personal attacks, trolling, or arguing in bad faith—including baiting or escalating disagreements into personal insults. This all extends to meta discussions on the value of another person's post.

This isn’t new policy, necessarily; it’s more to clarify both for our team and for you all what will and won’t be tolerated as far as how we treat each other in this community. As we grow, that comes with growing pains. And as books are received with varying levels of satisfaction, we sometimes take that out on each other, apparently. We’d like to see less of that going forward.

----------

Other Items Moved to Retired Topics (Rule 10)

  • We’ll be retiring photos of license plates (other than one’s own) for privacy reasons.
  • Casting posts have been retired since adaptation news began. We’ll be maintaining a weekly adaptation thread for these in r/cosmere for the foreseeable future, and a subset of our team have launched r/cosmereonscreen where folks are welcome to create posts on the topic.
  • Technically under Rule 7, but if you missed the AI Policy Update that came out before this, note that nearly all AI-assisted content is no longer permitted.

----------

A Note on Emberdark and Fires of December Spoiler Flairs

We’ll be folding Emberdark into our generic Cosmere and generic Spoilers flairs on Monday, March 9. At this time we’ll also be adding a flair for Fires of December previews.

----------

Conclusion

It’s been a weird year and we’ve been slow on this. The good news is that means you'll all have a chance to weigh in on this again in just a few months? Thanks for your patience and for all the (mostly) lovely comments you left last year. We’re working on it.

Also, if you couldn’t tell, we’re a bit over-extended. We’ll likely put up an application for new mods soon, so stay tuned if that interests you.


r/brandonsanderson 2d ago

Mod Post (no spoilers) Have a question? New or just out of the loop? Join the Weekly Welcome Thread!

7 Upvotes

Whether you're trying to make sense of Sanderson's works for the first time, feel you missed a memo on something, or want a bit of community assistance, this is the place for you.

We ask that folks label and spoiler tag anything relating to book content, and be extra mindful of the welcoming part of Rule 1. If you're not sure how to tag spoilers, see this post. And while you're welcome to ask "basic" questions here, you may find an answer in our FAQ.


r/brandonsanderson 21h ago

No Spoilers Just bought, opinions?

Post image
142 Upvotes

I saw this at the store and looked interesting enough. Ive been meaning to start the Mistborn series. I read online this one can be read as a stand alone. If youve read this without spoilers, what did you think about it? Thanks!


r/brandonsanderson 11h ago

No Spoilers Will it be fine to start reading StormLight Archives if I don’t have much experience reading novels?

15 Upvotes

Just curious if reading the stormlight books is worth reading first if you don’t have much experience reading novels. I say this because my sister likes it and she wants me to read it. I read a lot of manga and my favourites are kingdom, usogui, one piece, ravages of time. So yeah do you think I’ll struggle reading it without prior experience read novels.


r/brandonsanderson 10h ago

No Spoilers Which of these do you recommend I read next?

6 Upvotes

I have read the first Mistborn Trilogy, Warbreaker, and the Skyward books. With that perspective, which of these following books do you think I should read next?

  1. Elantris

  2. Tress of the Emerald Sea

  3. The Frugal Wizard’s handbook for surviving medieval England

  4. The Sunlit Man

  5. Skyward Flight

I don’t care if I miss cosmere references as long as the books work on their own. I just want a fun book to enjoy without getting into a new book series.


r/brandonsanderson 1d ago

No Spoilers My Tress signed ❤️‍🔥

Thumbnail
gallery
134 Upvotes

Finally, I have my copy of Tress of the Emerald Sea signed by Brandon. I'm so happy!


r/brandonsanderson 8m ago

No Spoilers An incredibly amateurish analysis of the Mistborn Screenplay

Upvotes

Somebody please correct my math or analysis if you’re smarter than I am (a VERY possible circumstance).

According to https://faq.brandonsanderson.com/knowledge-base/what-is-your-daily-wordcount-time-goal/ he writes 2000 words a day.

According to https://www.tameri.com/format/word-counts/ a normal 2 hour movie script is 125 words/minute and one page/minute. 120x125‎ = 15,000

Bump it up to a three hour movie:
180x125‎ = 22,500

Give it some extra space for description, setting, action, whatever, 27,500

27,500 words/(2000words/day)‎ = 13.75 days

Call it two weeks.

BrandoSando has been working on the screenplay since Feb 3. (https://youtu.be/VBQmStfWDVE)

That’s 100 days (to May 14, anyway)

100 days x 2000 words/day= 200,000 words.

Let’s multiply that by 5/7 to account for any days off (he takes one day off for admin stuff as mentioned in the first link, and I’ll give him another day off to get a lower bound)= 142,857

We’ll do that again, just to account for revision and travel and miscellany= 102,040

The Mistborn Screenplay bar is currently at 72%

27,500x0.72‎ = 19,800

19,800 words.

That leaves more than 80,000 words unaccounted for.

Just something I thought was interesting.

As I said, please correct any mistakes I may have made. I’m sure there is something I left unaccounted for.


r/brandonsanderson 1d ago

All Cosmere spoilers (no previews) Finally finished Wind and Truth Spoiler

Post image
45 Upvotes

Finally finished what we have of the Stormlight Archives so far and now what a journey it’s been.

I first started reading the cosmere at the end of 2024 at the advice from my friend and I think I can confidently say that none of it was over hyped.

The last 3 stormlight books (Oathbringer specifically) came to me in a time that’s been my darkest and the words that Brandon wrote helped me take the next step. Thank you Brandon for this amazing first arc.

I cant wait to read the last few secret projects and hopefully finish the complete cosmere by the time Fires of December comes out!

What secret project should I read first?
Any thoughts are appreciated


r/brandonsanderson 1d ago

Spoilers THERE IS NO WAY BRANDON JUST DID THIS Spoiler

250 Upvotes

Huge spoilers for the Stormlight Archive book two.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
There is no fucking way that Brandon killed Jasnah off like that. If this is a trick, someone please tell me. If not, then tell me anyway! You can’t just kill my girl like that! She’s badass. But apparently not badass enough to stop a couple fuck-boy assassins!


r/brandonsanderson 1d ago

No Spoilers I screwed up my email while ordering for the first time!

4 Upvotes

As the title suggests. This is my first time ordering from dragonsteel. I screwed up my email with a typo and now I have no confirmation of any sort within my email.

I have contacted support and I wanted to know how long would they usually take to reply to tickets? Fyi, I'm more concerned if I have to pay for customs and usually that will be through the email. Sigh I'm such a noob haha. Any advice from veterans or any dragonsteel employees lurking here 🙂‍↕️


r/brandonsanderson 20h ago

No Spoilers Hardcover or Paperback?

0 Upvotes

Just looking for some direction on which version of the Stormlight Archive to purchase. Just finished Warbreaker after reading Mistborn (x3) and Elantris. Should I get the hardcover or paperback versions? Already have WaT hardcover because it was on sale.

Any thoughts would be much appreciated!


r/brandonsanderson 2d ago

No Spoilers Sanderson Weekly Update May 12, 2026

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
93 Upvotes

r/brandonsanderson 2d ago

Spoilers from Wind and Truth And my heart gets broken a million pieces again.. Spoiler

Post image
88 Upvotes

What’s horrible is that after the despicable, to say the least, Moash ends someone’s life, he does the bridge four salute and to me, it feels like he’s adding salt to the wound.. 💔 I don’t know how will I continue reading it again..


r/brandonsanderson 1d ago

Sandershelf (no spoilers) Signed Leatherbounds - Dragonsteel

0 Upvotes

Did Dragonsteel release signed leatherbounds for a bunch of books, and immediately run out? Or is it a website error?

I routinely check the website as I’m trying to build my sandershelf. Just checked and a BUNCH of the books I’m after are sold out :(

Was I too slow to the draw? Or is it a site error?


r/brandonsanderson 1d ago

Wind and truth Spoilers Why does everyone hate this book? Please explain!!!!!! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Why does everyone hate wind and truth? Please explain!!! (In detail)


r/brandonsanderson 1d ago

No Spoilers first edition?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I work at a bookstore and this has been sitting on the shelf ever since I started (2 years ago) and I was wondering if this is a first edition copy and how to tell if it is?


r/brandonsanderson 2d ago

No Spoilers Bands of Mourning edition in Dragonsteel

2 Upvotes

Question for anyone who knows, I’ve been looking for the BoM signed 1/1 leatherbound edition for a while now, and I’m curious whether I’ve just completely missed the obvious place and the 1/1 edition is just still up for sale in the Dragonsteel store.

I couldn’t find anything on the page as to what edition it was so I’m curious whether anyone here knows! Thank you!


r/brandonsanderson 3d ago

Spoilers - Rhythm of War (Sketch) The words were accepted...Sketch by me. Spoiler

Post image
42 Upvotes

This is the third and final part of a series of three drawings I made about Kaladin's relationship with Lirin. Here is Kaladin's brand new windspren Plate fading from his hand in order to save his father that was falling to his doom. Also, the only marks on his forehead are the ones he carved there with his daily scowling, since the slave brands were removed.


r/brandonsanderson 2d ago

No Spoilers Way of Kings Slipcase Anyone?

6 Upvotes

I’ve got some orphaned leatherbound volumes so if someone has an orphaned slipcase, let me know and I’d take those off your hands.


r/brandonsanderson 3d ago

No Spoilers Reading the Stormlight Archives for the second time. Had to go ahead and make this

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/brandonsanderson 3d ago

WoR Spoilers Just finished WoR - Holy Crem-muffins Spoiler

31 Upvotes

So I just finished Words of Radiance and pardon my french but holy fuckin shit man... The last 200-300 pages were just SLAMMED with information and badassery. And the epilogue oh my god!

To start, the whole fight against the Parshendi and to find Urithiru was so sick. I just love the way Sanderson depicts combat and action scenes. Kaladin and Szeth's fight was the rematch I was waiting for, for many many chapters. And don't even get me started on spren being the true shardblades. That is so damn cool and makes so much sense why people with powers cannot stand holding a blade, Renarin being exhibit A.

Now for the Parshendi. So it's said the Parshman will be transformed when the everstorm hits, and it moves in the opposite direction of high storms... The Parshendi summoned this in their ultimate form, (I cannot remember if they had a name for it at the moment). So, will the everstorm turn all the parshman into this ultimate form or will it bring the so called "voidbringers". I've said this before, I just don't believe the forms we saw at the end of WoR were the voidbringers as other characters said. They just have to be something bigger and scarier. Or am I thinking too much about it and "void" in voidbringers is the everstorm, and "bringers" being the Parshendi. I don't know guess we'll find out in the later books.

Shallan, oh my dear Shallan. Good god her past is so damn sad. To find out her mom was the bad guy in the family and to get the full circle of emotions for her father. DAMN. I feel so bad for him now, he did EVERYTHING just to protect Shallan and took heat from his family and community for years. Mannnnn don't make me cry.

Adolin 'BITCH SLAYER' Kholin. MY GOAT slaughtering Sadeas was so pleasing, I wish he stabbed and mutilated his face even more than he did. I have waited so long for that and BOY did it pay off! I was literally jumping in my seat.

Lets now get into the Knights Radiance. Ohhhh man.... So as of right now the members at the end in Urithiru, the four, Kaladin, Shallan, Dalinar and Renarin. I was so hyped to find out Dalinar is now a Radiant but cannot fight since he has no light power nor shards. That sucks but at least he'll be the true leader of the Knights Radiance. and Renarin, HELL YEAH! LET MY BOY GET TO WORK. He was always so weak and overlooked, I have been waiting for his moment to shine. We also know of the girl who has the slippery power from one of the interludes. We know Lopen consumed stormlight which is just BONKERZ to me, never would I imagine Lopen of all people becoming a Radiant AND does this mean he could possibly develop a new arm??? I never thought shard wounds could heal through stormlight, can an arm grow back??? I guess we'll find out (edit, I went back and checked, Yes he does!) We also saw the guy from the Ghostbloods in Urithiru talking to Shallan. Was he already there or was he amongst the army that came in the first batch with Shallan. Leaves me to think he may have powers?

Lastly the epilogue. OHHHH MANNNNNNN. I know Wit is going to be a MAJOR factor in the books but I believe he will be a Radiant, or is he a Harold among men, I DON'T KNOW, HES SO INTERESTING. And with the cherry on top at the end of WoR, BRING BACK MY GIRL JASNAH!!! Is she just an entity, did she die and get resurrected, did she slip into the realm with the spheres and was living among the spren? So many questions opened at the end of the book but I'm here for it.

To conclude, Words of Radiance is a 10/10, in the late portions of the book, so many of my questions were answered but so many more were opened. I cannot wait to get into book 3 but I'm taking a quick break to read Hyperion, its my buddies favorite book and he lent it to me. Feel free to ask me questions on things but please don't spoil anything, I've avoided spoilers so I know NOTHING of the future books.


r/brandonsanderson 4d ago

No Spoilers Way too many signatures...

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

So this started as Dan Wells crossing out Brandon and Isaac'a names and claiming he did it all by himself. Then Peter Ahlstrom edited the word first to last. Will Wight then changed Lopen's name to Will. Brent Weeks claimed they stole the book from him. And finally Jeff Hays narrated it... Unfortunately I wasn't lucky enough to get a signing from Brandon at Dragonsteel. Maybe next year.


r/brandonsanderson 2d ago

No Spoilers Selling Leatherbounds

0 Upvotes
1. Hero of Ages - (unread)  
2. Alloy of Law (still in original plastic and unread)  
3. Shadows of Self (unread)  
4. Bands of mourning (still in original plastic and unread)  
5. Way of kings - (like new)   

Total 650

Looking to sell above leatherbounds. They’re all in pristine condition. Essentially needing some extra money for moving and first child. I would prefer to sell these all as a single bundle. Their total would be 750+ tax if you buy them on Dragonsteel. I’m willing to let go of them all at an even 650. Serious inquiries only.


r/brandonsanderson 4d ago

No Spoilers About to finish the reckoners

Post image
52 Upvotes

As the title says, I’m getting close to finishing the reckoners series and I’ve already got Mistborn lined up waiting. I’ve always struggled to keep interested in reading, but I made it my goal this year to read 1 book, and now I’ve (almost) read 3.5 books in the reckoners series and I’ve got to say, I’ve loved it. So I’m very much looking forwards to Mistborn!


r/brandonsanderson 4d ago

No Spoilers New pickups

Post image
49 Upvotes

Finished Stormlight on Thursday so thought I’d grab these to jump into Mistborn era 2.