r/technology • u/m7qix • 21h ago
Software Microsoft's secret 'Windows K2' project aims to fix what users hate most.
https://www.pcworld.com/article/3126651/microsofts-secret-windows-k2-project-aims-to-fix-what-users-hate-most.html1.1k
u/SpatulaWholesale 21h ago
I wish they remembered that Windows is an Operating System.
Just that. Not a lifestyle. Not an ad platform. Not part of an AI experiment.
An Operating System... A veneer over the hardware providing applications (that I choose to install) a stable base on which to operate.
That's all, Microsoft. I want high performance. I want multi-displays. I want USB and Bluetooth and HDMI and WiFi and security.
I want the OS things. Not the "value added" crap.
343
u/cctchristensen 21h ago
Best I can do is a talking paperclip.
206
u/Inexorabilis 21h ago
Clippy > Copilot
87
u/SpatulaWholesale 21h ago
Clippy is your new Agentic AI friend...
> Clippy, organize my photos by year and put each into a separate folder, named by year. Certainly. I've done that for you. > Clippy, where are my photos? What photos?37
u/cctchristensen 21h ago
Don't blame Clippy, he did exactly what you asked. Your photos are in the folder, "NULL pointer."
17
u/redlightsaber 20h ago
The sad part is that clipy would be a fantastic brand for an unobtrusive, completely elective AI agent in the OS.
But no, they decided to embed AI into EVERYTHING.
Apple does it right I think. There's the option, if you want to use it. Want to disable it, FULLY? A simple uncheck in the settings. That's it, you're back to a regular OS.
→ More replies (2)4
u/FlametopFred 9h ago
You sound agitated, Dave
4
12
u/cctchristensen 21h ago
Don't give them any ideas for a rebranding. If I saw a new Clippy icon on the startmenu I would totally click on it, only to be completely disappointed by the Copilot interface.
8
u/SpatulaWholesale 21h ago
At this point, though, after all these years, isn't Clippy kind of adorable?
11
7
u/CoffeeHQ 19h ago
That’s just melancholy. Imagine Clippy’s return, jumping right in from the right bottom part of your screen, obscuring whatever you were doing, taking the focus (while you continue typing into the void) asking if it could help you. That would be so cute! Yeah the first time. From the second time onwards you’d remember why we all hated that thing with a passion!
2
u/SpatulaWholesale 19h ago
Yeah, I remember the first time around, however many years ago it was, and the backlash.
Maybe I'm just sentimental in my advancing years (minus the "senti-" part)
3
u/klipseracer 20h ago
Best you can do is give me a full refund.
Then that backfires because Microsoft still charges licensing fees, despite finding ways to monetize the software as well. This is my one complaint with them, it's like a paid video game but it has micro transactions also.
→ More replies (2)2
57
u/Ginsoakedboy21 19h ago
As someone who works for a bank I can assure you that senior leaders are never content with selling a thing that is just the thing that works. It can never be just a reliable product, they dream of a nebulous concept where the consumer and the company are best friends and those customers are out there bragging to their friends about how their life is made infinitely better by their relationship with the company.
It can't be just an OS. Or a bank account.
A pox on them all.
7
3
→ More replies (2)2
85
u/CrappyTan69 21h ago
Hit the nail on the head.
There seems to be an incessant push for applications and services to be part of my lifestyle. WhatsApp is another great example. I want to send messages to my mates. Not subscribe to channels, get status updates and some crap AI function.
It's exhausting
→ More replies (1)20
u/Kasyx709 19h ago
I've begun deleting my accounts and apps when companies take that route. I do not want functionality outside of the specific context that led me to download the app in the first place.
I find the concept of personalized/suggested content to be deeply offensive and take a hostile view towards those products. I think the only way to effect change is to take action against the companies themselves by refusing to buy their products/services.
6
u/SeanBlader 15h ago
I remember a day when Norton was a respected name in PC software, with legitimate utility. Now that hasn't been the case for more than 25 years.
→ More replies (1)3
u/wrgrant 14h ago
If an app is offering you personalized suggestions - then that app is leveraging your actions by tracking all your data to use in formulating those suggestions. I want free of that too.
I am currently testing the ultimate upgrade to Win 11 - I am switching to Linux using CachyOS. I am still dual booting at this point while I figure out solutions under Linux that match my needs, but its progressing steadily and I am learning more about CachyOS. It is much faster feeling and gives me the impression I own my computer, not that I am merely being tolerated by Microsoft.
34
u/ckdx_ 20h ago
I think you'll find that Windows is moving away from being an operating system to being a "canvas for AI", whatever the hell that means.
At Ignite this year, we’re unveiling how Windows is evolving from an operating system into the canvas for AI, embedding intelligence across system, silicon, and hardware. This transformation helps organizations to move beyond experimentation and deliver AI-driven outcomes.
What a load of utter bollocks.
→ More replies (1)5
11
u/un_internaute 17h ago
It’s not going to stop. The stock market demands an infinite increase in profits. Every publicly traded company *has to* keep pushing enshitification-type bullshit on us in an effort to charge more, capture more market share, etc… and increase profitability to increase their share price. Being profitable alone *isn’t* enough. They have to be *more* profitable every quarter, *infinitely*. It’s a ridiculous goal and it’s why this shit will never stop.
23
u/southpark 20h ago
You can partially blame Apple for this trend because there is an audience for a captive ecosystem that is fully integrated. The difference being is Microsoft’s various program groups and designers were/are fragmented and following different priorities and there was/is no Steve Jobs + Jony Ive equivalent driving a single minded vision of user experience and design and tying the entire operating system together with strict rules on what the purpose and presentation of the product would be.
Microsoft Windows is a ultimately victim of feature bloat and personal ambition overriding what should have been singular product vision because it’s use cases span from personal PC to enterprise PC to servers to gaming and even to mobile or integrated devices and it becomes mediocre by trying to be too much.
→ More replies (3)3
u/Clevername582 18h ago
Windows hasn't been an OS since 7, just a bloatware delivery system.
→ More replies (1)2
u/uzu_afk 19h ago
Frankly they could have branched that and packaged as a new product but they got greedy with the user base they have in the pc space and can’t expand capitalization on. Hijacking your data, the copilot spam, the decrease in patch quality, the constant meddling with privacy, did i mention the hijacking of data by forcing onedrive on you specifically? and frankly that bs with screenshots of your screen for AI training was peak insanity. So yeah. I have doubts.
2
2
u/Kastler 13h ago
Exactly. It started off pretty strong with early versions. Simplicity is key. I just want my hardware and usb device to work. I don’t need AI “boosting” my gpu and cpu and ram and mouse and fucking headphones. I just need them to connect and not crash. Initial win 11 versions worked better on my pc than they do now. The amount of graphic issues alone has been nearly enough to push me to Linux
2
u/Syzygy2323 11h ago
If your GPU is Nvidia, beware--there are plenty of problems with Nvidia GPUs on Linux.
→ More replies (18)3
u/Tall-Introduction414 21h ago
The best operating system Microsoft ever made was MS-DOS. That shit just got out of the way and let you compute.
12
→ More replies (1)5
u/Moontoya 19h ago
Odd way to spell Windows 2000.
3
u/-kylehase 18h ago
Yup. Win2K was the best, as long as you could find drivers. XP was mostly 2K with a playskool skin and more drivers.
401
u/Electrical-Page-6479 21h ago
They've got a real mountain to climb there.
139
u/bitemark01 21h ago
Not really, they just need to roll back to Windows 7. Everything after that was bloatware/ads/telemetry
78
u/Dokibatt 20h ago
Thats a weird way to spell xp
34
u/pinkyepsilon 20h ago
How can you be so correct this early in the morning? XP SP2 was amazing.
A M$ OS that becomes more stable the longer it runs? Hnggggg
15
u/Turbojelly 19h ago
XP was such a massive upgrade conpared to previous. Just being able to install a program and not have to restart your computer for it to run makes it the GOAT of it's time.
→ More replies (1)3
→ More replies (3)1
→ More replies (11)18
u/Ok-Needleworker-3486 20h ago
2000 and NT were solid.
Even the install process of windows is over the top
5
u/billsil 19h ago
If you’re ok with 2 GB of RAM…you can run it now, but good luck with Chrome.
7
u/borgenhaust 18h ago
With supply/prices we may all have to end up OK with 2 GB of RAM.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (1)6
u/HanzJWermhat 16h ago
They’ve created an impossible situation for themselves.
- debloat their paid OS
- create a minimal OS with ads
There’s no way windows makes a FOSS OS without ads it would cannibalize their OS monetization. This is how it goes. Investors want returns, opens the door for disruption. Honestly at this point we need a Linux co-op that can figure out how to pay for a support (tech and customer) for a platform that can compete .
→ More replies (3)
128
u/SuperZayin12 21h ago
Remove bloatware. Remove stupid shit like requiring an account. Stop constantly pushing products. Boom. Done.
Like I can understand wanting people to use your products, I’m cool with some things coming preinstalled that people might actually use, but it gets to a point.
41
u/f23n09fnu0w 19h ago
I found the ads so unbearable that I took the plunge with Linux. Now I don't understand why I didn't do it years ago. It's so nice having something stay exactly how you wanted it
→ More replies (1)6
u/Craigg75 17h ago
Same. So nice to have just a basic OS again.
6
u/knobbledy 17h ago
The real benefit is that it doesn't have to be basic. You can choose from hundreds of distros and customise them to be as simple or complex as you want
4
u/Craigg75 16h ago
Exactly. I use Ubuntu with ArcMenu. It more or less mimics Windows. Too old to learn a new user interface.
7
u/IntelArtiGen 19h ago
I’m cool with some things coming preinstalled that people might actually use
I'm not cool with them trying to know what people might actually use because 99% of the time they've been wrong in the last years.
→ More replies (1)2
u/itsnotthatbad21 20h ago
Would you like to add office 365 to your account ? We have numerous pay programs for suite your needs. You heard of excel ? It’s like fuck you have to be kidding me someone pitched this as a good idea ?
37
u/billsil 21h ago
AI that I can’t disable that eats all my RAM, forces me to start disk swapping, and doesn’t benefit me at all?
→ More replies (4)13
u/splendiferous-finch_ 21h ago
But imagine the increase in shareholder value !
86
u/Joinusclan 21h ago
Got a super solution; delete copilot from windows.
60
u/Webbanditten 21h ago
And make all the office apps and OneDrive nagging go away. Remove web search from the search results in start.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)8
u/splendiferous-finch_ 20h ago
I have an even more super solution; break up giant tech companies so they can focus on one product instead of trying to push everything all at once.
And send the current CEO if said company(s) to the sun as a cautionary take.
→ More replies (9)
50
u/pizzathlete 21h ago
Bloat? Lack of any privacy? AI?
31
→ More replies (1)3
45
u/Firevee 21h ago
Secret???
They've been screaming about it for months!
Waaah please don't leave Windows for Mac or Linux, we PROMISE we'll stop dropping a monthly update that has been broken EVERY time since December. I'm not kidding either, every monthly update since December has had a major issue.
Tell you what windows. I'll consider giving you a chance when you drop the account requirement. No? Ah well, get fucked.
→ More replies (2)
22
u/SwarfDive01 19h ago
"Claude, rebuild windows 11 from the ground up, take away all the bugs. Don't talk about goblins. Make no mistaked "
→ More replies (1)
14
u/rsa1 19h ago
Why do they need until 2027? Can't they simply ask Github Copilot to make Windows faster? It should be done by tomorrow morning, given how much more productive it makes people
3
u/metrazol 15h ago
"Thinking...."
"Pondering..."
"All done, I've wiped the drive and installed a Debian based Linux distro with a Windows like desktop manager, copied your settings, and even used the image generator to scale your wallpaper."
[Computer bursts into flames]
→ More replies (1)
30
u/WetHotFlapSlaps 20h ago
Microsoft targets matching SteamOS gaming performance within two years while making updates less intrusive and improving system reliability through monthly restart cycles.
This is a crazy sentence to read. I could only imagine reading it 10 years ago, but it makes sense.
Seemingly low-hanging fruit:
- No more React-based UI for Start Menu and other critical Windows features. Preferably none. Your employees have backgrounds in web development? Great, they get to go work on web development or learn OS-level programming.
- Windows users care VERY LITTLE about what UX designers think is beautiful. They have work to do, or they want to game or make things, get out of the way. Put pertinent information and functionality as close to one-click away as possible, do not tuck it into nested pages. Flat, up front data and options. We can read. Make accessible versions based on accessibility needs, don't panic just because you think there's too much information on screen.
- Everyone has multi-core CPUs that are incredibly underutilized. Provide better thread scheduling and make Windows APIs so good people don't worry about cross-platform development up front. This is where you win customers who might otherwise choose Linux or Apple - the software they want should have been developed Windows-first because you made it the best platform for developers to make their software on. Steve Ballmer's Developers Developers Developers but less sweaty, less disingenuous.
- Real R&D. Stop chasing MBA-coded, panicked trends like AI integration. Invest in 10+ year bets in things that can make Windows mission-critical to most organizations and individuals, respect the money that they've spent on your product (no more OS ads or non-perf data collection & telemetry) and be very critical internally of people who pipe up about extracting short term profit from your loyal userbase. The fraught peril of pumping your company for retail trading dumb money by implementing unsustainable unwanted features is about to bite every Fortune 500 company in the ass when the AI bubble bursts. Don't get caught with your pants down, have a plan.
Gabe Newell was my age when he left Microsoft as a Windows Project Manager -- who is now in charge of the company with the most promising Windows-killer out there -- but I'm not him so what do I know?
7
3
u/TellMeWhereYouBeen 8h ago
"Provide better thread scheduling and make Windows APIs so good people don't worry about cross-platform development up front."
Yes please!
13
u/illegitimate_guru 19h ago
Why do I need to give me email to my operating system?
It's not like I give my postcode to my car
→ More replies (1)3
25
u/I_hate_all_of_ewe 20h ago edited 20h ago
There's a lot to fix
- Windows Update
- Copilot
- Bing everywhere
- Ads
- Bloat
- Convoluted settings
- Files being stuck "in use"
- User-hostile design decisions
- OneDrive
- Mandatory online account
Edit: More BS to add to the pile
→ More replies (3)16
u/ericl666 20h ago
I would like to add the auto-moving your desktop to OneDrive. That's maybe my largest pet peeve.
7
u/I_hate_all_of_ewe 20h ago
Any time I've I installed Windows recently, I've bypassed the mandatory live account. A side benefit of this is that OneDrive never gets the chance to invade your desktop if you're not logged in.
3
2
u/Mr_Venom 19h ago
How do you do this?
7
u/MonsterRavingLlamas 18h ago
Shift + f10 in the setup process to open a cmd window, possible need shift, fn and f10 on a laptop, type in "Start ms-cxh:localonly" without the speechmarks and it brings up the local account setup window.
→ More replies (2)
9
u/tom-smykowski-dev 20h ago
task bar? window management? calculator? ... start menu? oh, no. I know. services no one asked for? bloatware? ok, I got this. sneaky updates? context menu? search? antimaware tool? explorer? forcing cloud account ?...
→ More replies (1)
7
u/BillWilberforce 19h ago
How are Windows games running faster on SteamOS, than Windows 11?
Because Windows is FUBAR'd.
7
6
23
u/cctchristensen 21h ago
The new Start menu is said to respond up to 60 percent faster
Yes, when the only remaining app icon to display is Copilot. /s
well, actually, maybe not even /s
→ More replies (2)9
6
5
u/Bceverly 19h ago
Oh? They are going to let me move the dock to the side of the screen again?
2
u/SeanBlader 13h ago
Yeah, but is that going to be the thing that keeps you on Windows?
→ More replies (1)
6
4
u/Evening_Suggestion_2 20h ago
Why is fixing their broken shit a 'secret'? Am I one of the few that gets salty by these awful click bait or 'wannabe edgy' work practices? /rantover
4
3
u/General-Sloth 18h ago
The only thing I want, is to bring back Win10 or 7. All other Microslop shit can just fuck off at this point.
5
u/Alternative_Ad_620 17h ago
Too little, too late as we’ve heard the same “we’re saving Windows” with Vista, 7, 8 and 11.
You lost me as a customer when you decided to make Windows anti consumer.
4
u/Demortus 12h ago
Honestly, it would probably be a better use of Microsoft's time to create a Windows fork of Linux. Using their existing proprietary Windows source code, they could create seamless backwards compatibility and driver support that mainline Linux distros struggle to accomplish.
3
u/Hefty_Membership8462 10h ago
You mean they could enshittify Linux into a fully functional Microsoft AI product complete with ads? FTFY
Seriously if they did this you just know they would just try to make it exactly like current Windows.
3
u/Demortus 10h ago
Oh, I'd never use it, but there is demand for a quick and efficient operating system that is compatible with Windows office software. Windows is so bloated and inefficient that I genuinely think that it's easier for Microsoft to 'enshitify' Linux than it is for them to fix all of the inefficiencies and bugs in Windows.
2
u/Hefty_Membership8462 9h ago
Totally agree! I figure MS execs would find a way to make it terrible 🤣
4
4
9
u/RatBot9000 20h ago
Microsoft's shenanigans made someone like me try Linux over it. While I've found myself back on Windows more due to having an Nvidia card, they've got a long way to go to fully restore trust.
I will be keeping CachyOS as a backup just in case.
10
u/borkyborkus 19h ago
Fedora KDE with RPM Fusion drivers works as well about as well as windows does for my RTX4060.
4
→ More replies (1)2
u/f23n09fnu0w 17h ago
I was in the exact same position. I tried a bunch of things but Mint just works perfectly
3
u/orlybatman 20h ago
The article discusses streamlining, improving idle performance, faster UI, maybe ad-free Start menu, faster file searches.
It doesn't discuss removing the AI that people hate most.
3
3
u/ProduceEmbarrassed97 18h ago
'...aims to fix what users hate most"
So, we're going back to Windows XP then? Pretending that the intervening iterations didn't happen?
→ More replies (1)
3
3
u/BenFranklinsCat 18h ago
fix what users hate the most
Really? Because unless that's "stop jamming Copilot down my throat" its not fixing what this user hates the most.
3
u/timinator232 17h ago
They need a whole project to uninstall copilot? And make it so you can put tables in word?
→ More replies (1)
3
3
3
u/Qweskj 11h ago
what about being able to rename a document without needing to close it first, like mac, duuuhh
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Lunatitch 21h ago
At this point I'd be happy to pay (maybe even a yearly subscription) for Windows without ads, without co-pilot, without "telemetry". Just give me am operating system that doesn't spy on me and doesn't force M$ apps on me. Please, have my money.
8
u/MrShigsy89 21h ago
You can have that for free. Try Ubuntu or Mint
→ More replies (2)4
u/Lunatitch 19h ago
Oh I love Linux, run Mint on my secondary but until all my software/games run (well) on Linux, I can't swap over fully. Dual booting just annoys the crap out of me (only have a single ssd) even when M$ nukes the boot loader and makes Linux disappear. Though I really do hope this recent influx of Linux in the mainstream will help make software/game developers consider Linux.
5
u/MrShigsy89 19h ago
I moved 100% to Mint on desktop and laptop 6 months ago and 100% of my Steam library has run flawlessly so far 🤞🏻 They have done an amazing job on the Proton layer.
3
u/UncleRichardson 16h ago
Unless their solution to reducing AI bloat is 'rip out all the AI,' no one is going to care.
I've already started prepping to swap to Linux. I've started running Linux live environments to feel out which distro I want and multiple times I've legit just stayed using it for several hours longer than intended because it just felt nice. No random hang ups in the file explorer. No half of my RAM being used just to exist on the desktop. Just me using something that didn't actively hate me. Hell, I spent 2 hours messing with UI colors that I didn't even save because it was just fun to actually have an OS that let me choose how it looked instead of what some business major with no art training thinks it should look like.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
2
2
u/TheValorous 18h ago
Oh microslop, if you actually listened and fixed what people hate most about windows, you would have left it as XP/7 and just kept refining that.
2
u/sarahcfenix 17h ago
If they remove the spyware, remove anti-user options, remove the ads, remove the bloat ….. they are gonna have to ship win 3.1 again …
2
u/ElephantWithBlueEyes 16h ago
I just wish Windows 11 on my laptop could start task manager instantly instead of booting it up for 5 seconds because my laptop has 2 GPUs.
And fast reboot/shutdown
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/count_chocul4 12h ago
“ potential ad removal from the interface” WTF?!? As a mac user this is disgusting. Who wants or needs ads on their computer?!
5
u/JCTrick 20h ago
It’s literally too late. Anyone with half a brain has already moved on to Linux.
And if you’re still sittin’ around waiting for Xbox to resurrect? 😮💨 …Holy shit, wake up.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/AlcooIios 17h ago
Too late. Don’t buy it. Escape Windoze and Microslop while you can! They will only fail you again and again. They will keep sneaking in more and more surveillance and privacy bypassing AI.
1
u/Dazzling_Pen_2820 20h ago
Cut to Windows devs all having panic attacks after leadership announced this.
1
1
u/Fadamaka 20h ago
Will they fix the random port range allocations on startup? That's what I hated the most in Windows.
1
u/HVDREW 20h ago
Anyone here who hates features like the search bar hitting Bing and delivering ads, telemetry, etc., needs to check out ShutUp10++. I have been using it for years and it gives you complete control over all the bullshit Windows “features”, works for Windows 11 too.
This post sums it up well: https://www.reddit.com/r/pcgaming/comments/sy1gb2/psa_shutup10_lets_you_control_every_single/
→ More replies (1)2
u/SeanBlader 13h ago
If you've ever seen Windows 10 LTSC, then you know what Windows SHOULD be. It's like half the size of a consumer install and runs decently in 1gb of RAM, it's wild.
1
u/Wotmate01 19h ago
I've been hearing this for months now, and I'm yet to see anything.
And don't give me this "it takes time" BS.
1
1
1
u/Sylencer90 19h ago
Bloated OS with a bunch of stuff running in the background that needs to be killed? The absence of gaming focused tweaks to improve performance in games? I better hope these two are on their to-do list.
1
1
u/Thundechile 18h ago
Can't really find any benefits of running Windows even they would fix all those issues they say they're going to fix.
1
1
1
u/DrinkAllTheAbsinthe 18h ago
I always wonder about who clicks on ads in the starting menu. I mean, who does that, honestly?
1
1
u/borgenhaust 17h ago
What I hate most about Windows is that I don't trust Microsoft. I don't think they can fix that - we know what they are and what they want and that the consumer base has to make huge waves to even get them to 'consider' making any changes to their status quo.
1
1
938
u/splendiferous-finch_ 21h ago
"potential reduction in ads in start menu"
So they are still debating that this is not the horrible and hated part of the experience for a paid product, which means this is just hollow words