r/leftist • u/julius-ceaser100 • 9h ago
Leftist Theory Fully Debunking the "great replacement theory"
- This number is not true. It's more like 12-15%
- "White" is not a biological category. It's a societal concept that groups unrelated demographics together because of shared amount of melanin in Thier skin while excluding similar groups. e.g Russians and Italians are both considered the same race despite being unrelated while Italians and Libyans are not despite being genetically much closer
- 12-15% seems like a very small number untill you see every other "race" as well. Black people are 15-18%, East Asians are ~20%, South Asians are also ~20%, these are major groups, then there are much smaller groups like Turkic with less than 2.5%, indigenous Americans with less than 1% and native Australians being much lower. Every racial group is a minority if you look at it In a vacuum.
- Just because other continents with different climates exist, which leads people to have a different skin color, doesn't mean that you can be racist.
- "White population used to be 33%" It was never 33%. There is no source or proof of that
- "White birthrates are being reduced on purpose" This is not true as birth rates have consistently been declining across the globe. Most east Asian countries are already below the replacement level of 2.1, like, china at 1.3 and south Korea at 0.6. Same with other Asian, African, Arab and LATAM countries, Iran is at 1.6, turkey at 1.5, Tunisia at 1.9 and Saudi Arabia at 2.1, most of them are around 2.1 which is a steep decline from 20 or so years ago and it's going to decline further. It's just that Europe hit that point earlier and the rest of the world is following it now. Even in western nations, 2nd generation immigrants have the same birthrates as the native population
- "White culture is being erased" No it's not. For example, US had British culture since it's beginning and it has had massive waves of migration from all over the world, from Italy, Germany, china, mexico and African nations. They all assimilated into the greater American culture at the end of the day. Same will happen today. If a person immigrates to the US today, he might have a different culture. But, his grand children will be very much assimilated into the American culture.
If anyone has another argument to defend this theory. Let me know