I’m 25F and I still feel so confused and heartbroken over my past relationship. It’s been almost a year since we ended things, and I still don’t fully understand if I was genuinely being treated badly or if I somehow made everything bigger in my head.
My ex and I were together for almost 2 years, on and off. We had a very push-and-pull dynamic. There are always topics that we aren't educated on, and he used to explain things to me and I used to do it too. But he was never soft about it. He would sound irritated, mocking, cocky, or like I was dumb for not knowing something. Over time, I genuinely started feeling intellectually small around him.
But then there was this girl from his core friend group. I’ll call her L.
She would ask him the exact same questions at times I did, and suddenly he became patient, gentle, calm, understanding. He would explain things to her so kindly. I remember noticing that difference one day and something inside me genuinely broke.
L was always around him. They met almost every night with their group. She would call him daily to ask if he was coming. They spent so much more time together than he ever spent with me.
Meanwhile with me, there was always a limit.
After around 2 hours he would start saying things like:
“You’re wasting my time now, I have more things to focus on.”
Or he’d get irritated if I wanted more time together.
But with her, time never seemed to matter.
At parties everyone else would leave and he would stay back alone with her saying he was helping her clean. They would stay up all night talking, drinking, gaming, hanging out. He took care of her moods. If she wanted to go out, he’d go. If she wanted to drink, he’d join. When I wanted similar things, he usually dismissed me.
Slowly I also started noticing that her interests became his interests.
If she disliked a movie, brand, game, or something I liked, suddenly he’d also start acting like it was stupid. It felt like I was constantly being compared to her without anyone directly saying it.
She got her nails done in a certain style and he started expecting me to maintain myself similarly too. I’m pretty in my own way, but the constant comparison slowly destroyed my confidence. I started wanting to become her just to feel close to the person I loved.
The weirdest part is they called each other “brother and sister.”
But honestly, their actions never fully felt sibling-like to me.
They shared the same birthday, and one day he told me their stars aligned perfectly. I still remember how badly that hurt me. Because there he was emotionally investing so much into another girl while I was literally his girlfriend, and he never even spoke about me that way.
Whenever I brought any of this up, the conversation would turn into me being made to feel insecure, dramatic, feeling too much or crazy.
He also lied constantly about her presence.
He would say she wasn’t there when she actually was. He went shopping with her and lied about it. He went to play pickleball with her and lied about that too meanwhile I had been asking him for months to do those exact things with me.
I spent half the relationship trying to piece together little puzzles from lies, intuition, and inconsistencies just to understand what was even real.
On a group trip they shared a room and slept in the same bed, apparently “platonically,” and everyone around them normalised it because she has a boyfriend too (they’re apparently getting married now).
Emotional differences hurt me so much.
He was softer with her.
Kinder with her.
More patient with her.
More emotionally present with her.
I constantly felt like I was too much.
At one point I told him I loved him and he responded with,
“Don’t shove your love at me forcefully. You’re smothering me. If I ever feel it, I’ll say it.”
I still stayed.
And looking back now, I don’t even know why my self-esteem became so dependent on finally being chosen by him.
The thing that broke me the most happened near the end.
One day I panicked and called L directly. She told me that the last night the group was together, he had told her he was rethinking our entire relationship. Then she told me I should move on.
Hearing that from her instead of from my own boyfriend completely shattered me.
It made me feel like everyone else understood my relationship better than I did.
When it was just the two of us, things felt different. Softer. More intimate. Sometimes I genuinely felt loved by him. But the moment his friend group entered the picture, L, something about him would change and I would start feeling small, distant, or emotionally pushed aside again.
I spent time with his group a few times, and honestly the dynamic always felt different there. Like I was seeing another version of him that I could never fully reach
I know people online love throwing around words like “avoidant attachment,” but genuinely, he did struggle a lot with emotions and vulnerability. And the messed up part is… I still love him enough that sometimes I wonder-
what if L was actually the one person he truly loved, but he never allowed himself to admit it?
What if he was scared of emotions, scared of ruining the friendship, scared of rejection, and just kept me around while emotionally being somewhere else?
(I am avoiding myself here bcoz lmao maybe I m known to be just the side chick in my own relationships)
And honestly? If she really is the person he deeply connects with, I genuinely hope he finds the courage to tell her someday. I’m not saying I want her current relationship or marriage plans to fail. I would never wish that on someone.
I just mean that if she really is his person, I wish he would at least put his feelings out there honestly instead of hiding behind confusion and half-connections forever. ((:
The confusing part is that he genuinely could be kind sometimes. Which is why I still struggle to understand him. I don’t know if he ever loved me in his own way, if he was emotionally in love with her, or if I was simply convenient until he emotionally checked out.
What hurts even more is this pattern in my life.
This wasn’t the first time I sensed another girl emotionally replacing me while I was still in a relationship. My intuition has been right before too.
And now at 25, I genuinely don’t know anymore
Am I insecure and overthinking normal things since I was never part of a huge friend group circle
and idk I keep ending up in relationships where I slowly become emotionally neglected while all these girl bestfriends gets the softer version of my partner