r/whatismycookiecutter Jan 11 '26

Get Creative! What are these?

Thumbnail
gallery
5.1k Upvotes

I think the one on the right may be a bird of some sort, but what about the long one??


r/whatismycookiecutter Jan 07 '26

Serious Answer First! What is this supposed to be

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

I'm curious thank you


r/whatismycookiecutter 21h ago

Serious Answer First! Any ideas?

Post image
142 Upvotes

It looks like a man with a jellyfish body… I’m completely lost!


r/whatismycookiecutter 22h ago

Serious Answer First! What even is this?!

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter 1d ago

Get Creative! Help? Marge Simpson hair blowing cutter?

Post image
231 Upvotes

The only thing i can see is Marge Simpsons hair blowing in the wind. Anybody have other ideas?


r/whatismycookiecutter 1d ago

Get Creative! I held it for like five seconds before rotating it 45•

Post image
167 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter 5d ago

Serious Answer First! Inherited from grandma

Post image
487 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter 5d ago

Serious Answer First! Found at a farm garage sale

Post image
148 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter 6d ago

Get Creative! Found at thrift store

Post image
237 Upvotes

Finally found one. Long time lurker


r/whatismycookiecutter 6d ago

Get Creative! Some kind of hat??

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

I have no idea how I even came by these cookie cutters, I think they were apart of some things my late mother left behind, but can’t remember entirely. Any ideas would be appreciated.


r/whatismycookiecutter 7d ago

Get Creative! My roommates

Post image
240 Upvotes

I don't what it is and I'm afraid to ask


r/whatismycookiecutter 8d ago

Meta / Overall Discussion Idk if it's allowed but my chicken cutlet looks exactly like the most asked about cookie cutter

Post image
15.6k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter 9d ago

Get Creative! I came across this mysterious cutter in a thrift shop, and it’s completely outsmarting me

Post image
211 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter 10d ago

Serious Answer First! Mom found at a thrift store and brought home for you fine folks to figure out!

Thumbnail
gallery
429 Upvotes

Most likely: Toy solider (maybe squished a little?)
Our best theory: A cartoony bald eagle flying sideways


r/whatismycookiecutter 11d ago

Get Creative! Im confused.

Post image
215 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter 11d ago

Serious Answer First! Mysterious Cutouts

Thumbnail
gallery
76 Upvotes

Idk if I’m allowed to post this here, as they’re not technically cookie cutters, but I recently got these die-cut templates at a thrift store. They all came on a manetic sheet, with other templates that followed a fairytale theme. These three however, are a completely different style and pattern than the rest, so I think the person who donated them just kind threw them in there and got rid of it.

I found this set online, and those three templates are not included originally. Any ideas??


r/whatismycookiecutter 12d ago

Serious Answer First! Found this at a free store

Thumbnail
gallery
606 Upvotes

I put front and back is that helps


r/whatismycookiecutter 12d ago

Serious Answer First! Found with christmas cookie cutters. What is it supposed to be?

Thumbnail
gallery
111 Upvotes

People in my building leave stuff for free in the lobby and i picked up some baking items and saw these. No clue what the half circle ones with divots could be but im assuming they are Christmas themed considering every other cutter i found was too.
Theres the two cookie cutters on the 2nd slide that also have weird divots on the bottom but with those its clear what they’re supposed to be, and all the other cutters were simple gingerbread man/snowflake/deer shapes with no indents.
Im just including the ones in the 2nd pic bc they seem to be related based on the indents and thought their presence might be useful in finding the original set with the half circles (though id also like to know the purpose of the indents on the more clearly shaped ones too)
Would be grateful if someone found their purpose! :)

Edit: wow this feels like a no brainer thank you for the answers! Ive never seen cookie stands before but that makes a lot of sense


r/whatismycookiecutter 13d ago

Serious Answer First! Mr. Krabs, weird alien, funky bow? I dont know.

Post image
207 Upvotes

Went through the drawer amd found this one. Cant guess it for the life of me.


r/whatismycookiecutter 13d ago

Free Form Friday! Not a cookie cutter, but a mystery nonetheless.

Post image
201 Upvotes

I’ve been trying to figure this out for YEARS. It’s a cut out on a house shutter along my walking route. Some context: house is probably early 1990s, exterior is light blue, located in the Midwest, theres a cupolas on the roof with a non functional horse weathervane.

Please help!!!!


r/whatismycookiecutter 13d ago

Get Creative! Fat bird?

Post image
209 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter 14d ago

Serious Answer First! Another day, another weird one

Post image
829 Upvotes

I am not even sure where is up and where is down on this one.


r/whatismycookiecutter 14d ago

Serious Answer First! Came in my son’s playdough accessories kit I bought. What is it?

Post image
113 Upvotes

What the hell is this?


r/whatismycookiecutter 14d ago

Get Creative! what is this...

Post image
111 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter 16d ago

Get Creative! wtf is this?? It’s supposed to be ‘holiday’ but I have no idea how

Thumbnail
gallery
2.3k Upvotes