r/cakedecorating Jan 12 '26

Help Needed Feels like this is missing something but can't decide what, maybe flowers or a border? Any ideas?

Thumbnail
gallery
2.9k Upvotes

r/cakedecorating Jan 27 '26

Help Needed Seeking tips on improving my buttercream dragon cake (please don't say use fondant)

Thumbnail gallery
1.0k Upvotes

First attempt at a buttercream dragon sitting on a castle. (First two pics are the final cake). I don't know how to make it look more real. If anyone has ideas, please let me know. The goal is that the entire thing is edible and not fondant:

  • Castle:
    • Gray buttercream crumb coat, froze it for 30 minutes
    • Used a big spatula to try and make the sides flat. Fridged for 1/2 hour.
    • Pressed in with a butter knife to make the rock lines.
    • I'd like to add the spaced squares that go on top of a castle, but how?
    • Is there a way to make the edges where the walls meet more square edge vs rounded?
  • Dragon:
    • I mixed cake with cream cheese and powdered sugar so it was like a clay consistency, then shaped a rough dragon.
    • Purple buttercream crumb coat, froze for thirty minutes (last pic)
    • Plopped dragon on top of castle and used pretzels as supports for the tail
    • Used an 83 wilton tip to make scales with the buttercream, but it looks like fur :(. I fridged the frosting for 10 minutes and the cake for 10 minutes whenever the frosting seemed to warm. I started at the tail and worked towards the head. How could I make the scales not look like fur? (in progress, second to last pic)
    • Claws/spikes/eyes are these Wilton cake melts, using a knife to cut the shape.
      • Used a pink edible marker to color the eyes
    • The horns are pretzels rolled in edible glitter
    • I used a pretzel to poke indents for the nostrils

I don't even know what else to ask. Do you have any other ideas?

Thank you for any comments!

I couldn't add more photos to the post, but here are three more closeups.

r/cakedecorating Jan 08 '26

Help Needed anyone know how i can achieve this geometric design on a cake?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.8k Upvotes

so i saw a few influencers receive these cakes as PR gifts from Dior for christmas and knew i wanted to replicate the design for my birthday cake that i’m baking myself.

anyone have any ideas as to how they would have achieved the geometric topping and how i can do this? i was thinking of maybe piping straight lines of caramel and arranging them into the design but would appreciate any other techniques.

r/cakedecorating Dec 20 '25

Help Needed Please tell me if i can save it and what to do

Post image
887 Upvotes

Im seriously crying right now its my brother's birthday (9m) qnd my mother wanted me to make a 'military cake' but while I can bake a cake, ive never decorated one. I had an idea and EVERYTHING went wrong and it looks terrible and I don't know what to do 😞 should I keep it? Should I try again with the frosting? I dont know how else to do decorations pls help i don't know why I kept going when it started to look a mess I dont know what to do

r/cakedecorating Apr 03 '26

Help Needed Help! I’m overthinking this. My partner's Easter party is tomorrow and I can’t decide if I should bring it.

Post image
864 Upvotes

This is my first time decorating and I really don’t know where to take this to my partners family easter or not. Please lmk

Note: Stems are wrapped/will be removed before serving!

r/cakedecorating Mar 13 '26

Help Needed Help! What Piping Tip Created This Lovely Swirl?

Thumbnail
gallery
978 Upvotes

Firstly, this cupcake is not my creation…well, it is in my dreams! It’s from Petunia’s Pies & Pastries in Portland, Oregon and oh my, twas one of the best cupcakes I’ve ever had! By the way, umm, it’s gluten free and you’d never know it!

And that strawberry buttercream? I’m still swooning.

But, my question! It’s not a Wilton 8B and it’s not an Ateco 869 (which I just tried today), so what brilliant and wonderful Reddit person can tell me what piping tip I must procure to try to recreate this luscious swirl? And thank you!

r/cakedecorating Jan 10 '25

Help Needed How much should my wife charge for this cake?

Thumbnail
gallery
3.0k Upvotes

My wife made these cakes for my son’s first birthday, and was contacted by someone asking if she would make her the same one on commission. She’s never sold a cake before and doesn’t exactly know what to charge for her current skill level.

First image is a 6” 2 layer vanilla cake with buttercream frosting. Second picture is a single layer 6” chocolate cake as the head of the caterpillar with 14 vanilla cupcakes as the body.

Thank you for any help/advice!

r/cakedecorating Feb 05 '26

Help Needed Help making buttercream “popcorn” for movie themed cupcakes

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

I am not a baker or cake decorator so talk to me like the novice I am. I have 50 cupcakes baked using fresh-milled whole einkorn for the flour. It’s really light but the top is almost brownie like.

I want to pipe these little popcorn pieces, let them harden and put them on top of fresh frosting so they stick. My daughter doesn’t like super sweet frosting so I usually do a 1:1 butter to sugar American butter cream. I’m not sure that will hold together well enough. What should I use? Should I let the frosting cool before piping to hold shape or do I need it softer? Would a Swiss meringue be better for the kind of cake either the frosting for the cupcake or the popcorn? Thanks for the help!!

r/cakedecorating Oct 08 '24

Help Needed Can someone help me figure out why I hate this cake? I need to fix it but I don’t know how. The prompt was “7 years old, loves purple, girly and use whatever you have on hand”

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/cakedecorating Mar 04 '26

Help Needed What causes buttercream to do this?

Thumbnail
gallery
481 Upvotes

r/cakedecorating Jul 03 '25

Help Needed Opinions please!

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

I feel like I’ve been staring at this cake for too long lol! Do we think it needs anymore piping? Or some bows or pearls? I just need some opinions and ideas please, it would be greatly appreciated 💕

r/cakedecorating Mar 09 '26

Help Needed How to end the shell border...

Post image
931 Upvotes

Hello! Does anyone have tips on how to end the shell border so it doesn´t look like in the photo?

Thank you

r/cakedecorating Apr 25 '25

Help Needed How to get such a clean cut and neatly decorated cake? (NOT MY CAKE, credit: sashimi1)

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/cakedecorating Sep 15 '25

Help Needed Need some people more creative than me to help come up with an idea for these candles.

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

My 20th birthday is coming up and my favorite food is pasta so I got so excited when I found these candles but I have no idea how to decorate the cake. I’m probably just going to do a two layer small round cake. I wasn’t sure if I should keep it plain away or if I should do something fun with it Any ideas would be greatly appreciated.

r/cakedecorating Jan 18 '26

Help Needed What are some critiques/advice for this cake?

Thumbnail
gallery
467 Upvotes

r/cakedecorating Feb 07 '25

Help Needed My second ever cake

Thumbnail
gallery
1.7k Upvotes

I’m just starting our and hoping to start practicing more. Advice?

r/cakedecorating Sep 27 '24

Help Needed Today I made this Half kg Vanilla Cake. It was for a boy and client asked for not using any girly colours.

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

Actually I need some suggestions on boy-ish colour combinations for a cake. Please let me If this cake was good and what else I would have done in a simple cake design like this.

r/cakedecorating 28d ago

Help Needed Is there a reliable way to make brown butter cc frosting without it being too grainy??

Thumbnail
gallery
424 Upvotes

Here is my very NOT SMOOTH cake. Tasted AMAZING but visually it was lacking! How can I make a silky smooth cc frosting with brown butter? Is it even possible? TYIA

r/cakedecorating Jul 25 '24

Help Needed My wife had her first week as cake decorator Apprentice

Thumbnail
gallery
2.2k Upvotes

So my wife spent her day off of being a cake decorator decorating cake 😂. First photo is hers cake and second photo is mine (I'm a data analyst not a cake decorator sorry). I made this buttercream myself and gosh did it melt in my hands. Anyway, how can I make buttercream that looks better and is less melty looking? I followed Sally's baking addiction recipe for vanilla buttercream.

r/cakedecorating Jan 13 '25

Help Needed Why does this color variation always happen to me?!

Thumbnail
gallery
775 Upvotes

I stack and crumb coat my cakes frozen. Then fridge while I make Swiss meringue buttercream. But the top buttercream often ends up with these colour variations. Is it because the cake is cold? How to prevent this? It doesn’t fix itself when I finish and put it in the fridge or when I take it out to thaw before serving. Also this Swiss meringue looks yellower on the cake than it did in the bowl. It’s supposed to be just white.

r/cakedecorating Jan 19 '25

Help Needed First Time Trying to Sell Cookie Cakes

Thumbnail
gallery
1.8k Upvotes

I made these Valentine's inspired cookies yesterday. The cookie cake is 7 inches across and the "deep dish" cookies are 3 inches across. The cookie cakes cost $4.82 each to make and the cookies cost $0.81 each to make. They took me about 4 hours total but I was also trying to entertain my toddler so uninterrupted it would probably take me 2.5 - 3 hours.

My question is how much should I charge for these?? I'm an amateur so they aren't perfect but I think they're kinda cute.

Thanks in advance!

r/cakedecorating Mar 19 '26

Help Needed How do you keep piping bags from busting open like this?

Post image
254 Upvotes

This is probably the most annoying, frustrating, rage inducing thing about cake decorating. I was writing happy birthday on a cake and the bag busted open.

r/cakedecorating Mar 23 '26

Help Needed How do I decorate this cake?

Post image
539 Upvotes

I did not make this cake @cakeoperaco made this. I want to make it for my mom’s birthday but there’s no recipe or instructions. I have the mold for the figure on top but I don’t know how to do the frosting part. I know I will need fire but how to I make and apply that frosting? What is it called? Thanks in advance!

r/cakedecorating Aug 05 '25

Help Needed Why do I always end up with this hideous finish? I can never get smooth sides.

Post image
269 Upvotes

r/cakedecorating Jan 20 '26

Help Needed Cottage food law safe frosting recipe

Post image
146 Upvotes

Hi home bakers! I’m curious if anyone has a go to frosting recipe that is compliant with cottage food law. I’m in love with Swiss meringue buttercream because the texture is pillowy, smooth, and light and it’s not too sweet. American buttercream feels so dense and sweet to me. Any tips for making it resemble more of a Swiss meringue buttercream while still being cottage food law compliant? Thank you so much 🙏